Judges To See Plea On Rejected Chief Justice Impeachment Shift

08 May, 2018, 01:08 | Author: Jeannette Greene
  • Cong goes to SC, challenging Naidu's rejection of CJI impeachment petition,…

After Vice President Venkaiah Naidu rejected the petition of Opposition MPs of the Rajya Sabha to initiate impeachment proceedings against Chief Justice of India Dipak Misra, 2 Congress MPs on Monday moved the Supreme Court regarding the impeachment of the CJI.

On 23 April, Naidu, Vice-President of India and Chairman of the Rajya Sabha, had rejected the impeachment motion, holding it was "neither legal nor desirable or proper" to admit it.

Senior advocate Kapil Sibal, who was one of the signatories of the impeachment notice in the Rajya Sabha, mentioned the matter for an urgent listing before a bench headed by Justice J Chelameswar, the senior-most after CJI Misra.

Allegations against Misra include involvement in a conspiracy to pay bribes in relation to a medical admission scam, dealing with a case in which he was likely to fall under the scope of an investigation, antedating an administrative order and abuse of administrative power in allocating cases in the Supreme Court.

The reason Sibal mentioned the case before Chelameswar's bench was made clear by Sibal himself, who told the court that since the case relates to CJI Misra, he couldn't mention it before the CJI to demand a date of hearing.

Bar and Bench reported that the constitution bench will consist of Justices AK Sikri, SA Bobde, NV Ramana, Arun Mishra and AK Goel.


In their joint petition, the MPs said that once a removal motion is signed by the requisite number of MPs the RS chairman has no option but to constitute an inquiry committee to investigate the charges.

The MPs, Pratap Singh Bajwa from Punjab and Amee Harshadray Yajnik from Gujarat, said they had challenged the decision because the removal motion was signed by more than 50 MPs as constitutionally required, and yet Naidu rejected it.

Both Justice Chelameswar and Justice Kaul went into a huddle and asked Sibal and Bhushan to come Tuesday so they could take a call on the issue. "This is the job of the Inquiry Committee", the petitioners contended. I have practised in this court for the last 45 years and the procedure is that whenever there is a petition against the CJI, it is mentioned before the bench headed by the seniormost SC judge. He said the CJI can not order for listing and hence the senior-most judge of the court must pass some orders as it was a matter of constitutional importance.

The petition called for a declaration that the Vice President as chairman of the Rajya Sabha can not exercise discretion and that he must set up an inquiry panel under the Judges' Inquiry Act, to probe the allegations against CJI Misra. This was the first time that an impeachment notice was filed against a sitting CJI.

Naidu had said that the notice lacked merit.

Recommended:

  • Molina has Surgery Following Foul Tip to the Groin

    Molina has Surgery Following Foul Tip to the Groin

    Cardinals left fielder Marcell Ozuna was more succinct. "That was a bad one", Matheny said, via ESPN . Molina immediately fell to the ground in pain and was replaced by Francisco Pena .
    Champions League and Europa League revenue

    Champions League and Europa League revenue

    Jurgen Klopp insists his only focus is on Liverpool's upcoming "semi-final" in the Premier League against Chelsea . For that, of course it helps massively if you have this obvious sign: being in the Champions League final .

    Mike Trout gets 3 hits, including triple, in Angels' win over Seattle

    Pujols joined Hank Aaron, Willie Mays and Alex Rodriguez as the only players in baseball history with 3,000 hits and 600 homers. Entering Friday , Pujols had hits off 966 pitchers, an impressive list that literally runs from A (Arroyo) to Z (Zambrano).
  • Bay Area Free Comic Book Day 2018 Guide

    Bay Area Free Comic Book Day 2018 Guide

    Since 2002, the first Saturday of May has been dubbed Free Comic Book Day . "It is our biggest day of the year". Popular series available this year include Pokemon, Doctor Who , SpongeBob, and Star Wars.
    NXP Semiconductors (NASDAQ:NXPI) Short Interest Update

    NXP Semiconductors (NASDAQ:NXPI) Short Interest Update

    The company was initiated on Tuesday, December 6 by Bank of America. ( NYSE:BX ), 15 have Buy rating, 0 Sell and 4 Hold. The company's stock had a trading volume of 29,969,398 shares, compared to its average volume of 4,961,868.
    Southwest Airlines to offer Hawaii flights from Sacramento

    Southwest Airlines to offer Hawaii flights from Sacramento

    Lastly, San Diego has flights to all four destinations Southwest intends to serve from Alaska Airlines and Hawaiian Airlines. On Thursday, March 22 the stock of Southwest Airlines Co . (NYSE:LUV) on Monday, April 30 with "Buy" rating.
  • Cristiano Ronaldo Champions League final concerns eased following Clasico injury

    Cristiano Ronaldo Champions League final concerns eased following Clasico injury

    But with Barca remaining on track to go the entire LaLiga season unbeaten, Iniesta was happy to be able to go out on a high. His first shot was saved by Marc-Andre Ter Stegen, the second fired wide of the far post.
    PM Khaqan Abbasi Says Elections Will be Held By Aliens

    PM Khaqan Abbasi Says Elections Will be Held By Aliens

    According to Abbasi, a retired judge or bureaucrat or a politician could become a caretaker prime minister. He also confirmed that no former army officer was recommended for the post.
    Rihanna Demotes Drake From Even The Friend Status And Ouch!

    Rihanna Demotes Drake From Even The Friend Status And Ouch!

    In an interview with The New York Times, he even said that he was her "pawn", but later retracted the statement. Rihanna winces slightly at the mention of the rapper's name before her eyes glaze over with cool indifference.
  • Lebanon Elections Syria Shadow

    Lebanon Elections Syria Shadow

    There are 583 candidates competing for 128 parliamentary seats, evenly split by law between Christian and Muslim candidates. While many polling stations faced similar issues of long queues, others appeared to be coping easily with the voters.
    Pakistan Interior Minister Ahsan Iqbal escapes assassination bid

    Pakistan Interior Minister Ahsan Iqbal escapes assassination bid

    Shahid Khaqan Abbasi, the prime minister, condemned the attack as Pakistan prepares for federal elections expected this summer. Police had increased security at the hospital and high-ups visited the medical facility to check the security arrangements.
    Donald Trump: Obstruction of Justice Charges 'Nonsense' in Russia Investigation

    Donald Trump: Obstruction of Justice Charges 'Nonsense' in Russia Investigation

    Yet when asked that same question by Congress at a public hearing previous year , he declined to provide that same reassurance. Comey said the country would be better off if "our leaders" tried to emulate them instead of "comparing them to Nazis".


Popular

Qantas pressured to adopt one-China policy over Taiwan
In a statement White House Press Secretary Sarah Sanders noted that President Trump "ran against political correctness in the United States".

French Minister Warns Air France Will "Disappear" Unless Crisis Stops
After protracted negotiations, management last week offered a 2% pay rise this year and an additional 5% over 2019-2021. France's economy minister on Sunday warned that the survival of Air France was now in the balance.

Spiders' men's and women's lacrosse teams celebrate NCAA tournament berths
If the bid for the Virginia men's team was a step toward returning to the sport's upper echelon, the women's program never left. Maryland enters the title game as the No. 3-ranked team in the nation, as the Terrapins now hold an overall record of 17-1.

Mourinho green light for Man Utd to sell Martial
And now, the Red Devils seem to be preparing yet another swap deal, this time involving a midfielder from London giants Chelsea . Anthony Martial has failed to hold down a regular starting spot under Jose Mourinho in the past two seasons.

Anti-Putin protests in Russian Federation
Navalny will be charged with organizing an unauthorized meeting, according to the Los Angeles Times . The rallies descended into clashes with police and hundreds of protesters were detained.

Yaya Toure leaves Man City as the Premier League's forgotten legend
Considering their successes of recent years, City have yet to find a way to truly celebrate their greats of this golden era. Guardiola also revealed the Brighton match will be focused on Toure saying goodbye to adoring fans at the Etihad Stadium.

Elon Musk goes on Twitter to defend his freaky earnings call behavior
I asked Musk how he thinks it will compare to the 2013 short squeeze that followed his 2012 warning to the shorts. Musk interrupted the analyst and dismissed his question, indicating that " boring " questions are "not cool".

Berkshire Hathaway bought additional 75 million Apple Shares in Q1 2018
Investors who do so may be totally missing the point, as Apple boasts a "wide, wide gap" against its peers, said Buffett, 87. Berkshire had $116 billion in cash at the end of past year , so has plenty of spare money to make big investments.

North Korea changes its time zone to match South
Trump also said then that the Southeast Asian city state of Singapore was also in the running to play host. "We now have a date". It remains unclear if Kim has relaxed that demand as he turns to diplomacy with adversaries after a year of escalating tensions.

Radio station bans Kanye West's music following controversial slavery comments
Ellen DeGeneres had two questions for Kris Jenner when she dropped by her daytime talk show - and they both involved Kanye West . Kanye West doesn't listen to the opinions of mother-in-law Kris Jenner or wife Kim Kardashian , a new report claims.