2nd federal decide orders Trump administration to just accept DACA renewals

14 February, 2018, 18:15 | Author: Dustin Murphy
  • 2nd federal decide orders Trump administration to just accept DACA renewals

A federal judge in NY has ruled that the Trump administration can not end the Obama-era program created to protect from deportation young immigrants brought to the United States illegally as children.

It's the second time in less than two months that a USA judge found the rescinding of the program as proposed would be wrong.

"Defendants indisputably can end the DACA program", Garaufis wrote, referring to the Trump administration.

U.S. District Judge Nicholas Garaufis.

The case landed in the NY court after, when on September 5th Attorney General Jeff Sessions announced that the administration would end DACA on March 5th, NY Attorney Eric Schneiderman filed a lawsuit against the federal government saying the DACA repeal was based on "racial animus" against Latinos.

Garaufis wrote there wasn't evidence in the record to support the government's argument that officials had made a decision to end the program out of concern that courts would strike it down, similar to the injunction that blocked the Obama administration's Deferred Action for Parents of Americans and Lawful Permanent Residents program. Government lawyers argue the size and importance of the program warrants an immediate and definitive ruling on DACA's termination.


Garaufis, however, said the government was "erroneous" in its conclusion that DACA was unconstitutional and that it violated the Administrative Procedures and Immigration and Nationality acts.

Garaufis' ruling follows a similar injunction from San Francisco federal judge William Alsup in January. "Based on its review of the record before it, the court concludes that defendants have not done so".

A second federal judge issued a ruling temporarily blocking the DACA program from ending. "The Justice Department argues that DACA was an illegal overreach by the Obama White House, and was likely to be overturned in court". Trump gave lawmakers a March 5 deadline to pass legislation that would end the program, but he was met with resistance from Democrats and judges alike.

"Today's order doesn't change the Department of Justice's position on the facts: DACA was implemented unilaterally after Congress declined to extend these benefits to this same group of illegal aliens".

The administration's March 5th date was meant to force Congress to pass legislation by that time to replace the program in exchange for funding Trump's campaign promise to finish the border wall and increasing immigration control. "The Department of Homeland Security therefore acted within its lawful authority in deciding to wind down DACA in an orderly manner. As such, it was an unlawful circumvention of Congress, and was susceptible to the same legal challenges that effectively ended DAPA", O'Malley said.

Recommended:

  • Tai Tuivasa Discusses His UFC 221 Bout With Cyril Asker

    Tai Tuivasa Discusses His UFC 221 Bout With Cyril Asker

    Luke Rockhold can win the interim middleweight title but Romero won't claim the belt if he wins the fight. Rockhold appears to be in good spirits, though, who took to social media to congratulate the victor .
    Winter Olympics 2018: CAS upholds Russian ban

    Winter Olympics 2018: CAS upholds Russian ban

    An IOC spokesperson said, "We welcome this decision which supports the fight against doping and brings clarity for all athletes". In a telephone interview, Reedie told The Associated Press: "I am delighted at the decision and the way they expressed it".
    Auto Expo 2018: Emflux Motors unveils e-bike prototype

    Auto Expo 2018: Emflux Motors unveils e-bike prototype

    The company also launched Humsafar DLX- a passenger carrying vehicle and Humsafar 2000 (loader)- both diesel three wheelers. India's automobile market is now the world's 5th largest, with almost 3.8 million vehicles sold per year.
  • Eurostar confirms April launch date for London-Amsterdam

    Eurostar confirms April launch date for London-Amsterdam

    It will target potential converts by saying a London-Amsterdam Eurostar journey emits 80% less carbonthan the equivalent flight. These customers will see their journey time cut by 17 minutes as the time onboard is reduced from 2hr05 to 1hr48.
    At least three killed in Grand Canyon helicopter tour crash

    At least three killed in Grand Canyon helicopter tour crash

    A tourist helicopter has crashed in the Grand Canyon in Arizona, United States, killing three people and injuring another four. National Transportation Safety Board officials will investigate what caused the copter to go down, Bradley said.
    May brace sees England past Wales at Twickenham

    May brace sees England past Wales at Twickenham

    You fly a guy over from New Zealand and he has one big call to make. "And at this level I think that's pretty disappointing". You can not do anything about it.
  • Revenge? Puel is insouciant about Mahrez

    Revenge? Puel is insouciant about Mahrez

    The Algeria global failed to show up at the King Power Stadium after his move to the Etihad Stadium fell through. It's hard to resist against this team. 'I want to protect all the squad, it is the most important thing.
    VENEZUELA: Presidential Elections Scheduled For April 22

    VENEZUELA: Presidential Elections Scheduled For April 22

    The views expressed therein are not necessarily those of stlucianewsonline.com, its sponsors or advertisers. And the Venezuelan opposition is divided into several different factions.
    Up to 10 inches of snow expected by Friday evening in Chicago

    Up to 10 inches of snow expected by Friday evening in Chicago

    Snow across southern and central MI ranged from 7 inches on the western side of the state to about 5 inches in the Detroit area. The storm could dump up to a foot (30 cm) of snow in NY state as it picks up moisture off the Great Lakes, he added.
  • Google brings controversial AMP platform to Gmail

    Google brings controversial AMP platform to Gmail

    You can take a look at some of the early AMP Stories by searching for a publisher at this link on your phone. If you use Instagram , Facebook or Snapchat , then we assume you are pretty much aware of what Stories are.
    Olympic Alpine Skiing Schedule 2018

    Olympic Alpine Skiing Schedule 2018

    The women's slalom became the third Alpine ski race to be postponed at the Olympics . No one has ever won all five at an Olympic games, man or woman.
    Uber, Waymo reach self-driving auto  settlement

    Uber, Waymo reach self-driving auto settlement

    As part of the settlement, Waymo will get a 0.34pc stake in Uber, worth $245m (£177m) at its latest valuation. That's a win for Uber, considering the $1 billon settlement Waymo sought past year .


Popular

Chris Mazdzer wins USA's first-ever male singles luge medal
Today in PyeongChang, he was going for a third straight gold medal, and would become only the second man in history to do so. Austria's David Gleirscher took gold and Germany's Johannes Ludwig bronze.

United Kingdom foreign minister set to visit Rohingya refugee camp
Doctors Without Borders (Medecins Sans Frontieres) estimates 6,700 Rohingya died in the first month of violence. Mr Johnson visited a UNICEF child-friendly site where he saw the efforts being made to keep young people safe.

Winter Olympics: Teenager Red Gerard wins first USA medal
Norwegians Staale Sandbech and Markus Kleveland slipped up during their last shots, too, leaving only Parrot in Gerard's way. And he now can do what no other snowboarder has done since the discipline entered the Olympics: win two medals.

Plane Crashes Outside Moscow, 71 Believed Dead
Andrei Odintsov, the mayor of Orsk, said six psychologists and four ambulances were working with relatives in the small airport. Minutes after take-off, the plane slipped from radar coverage and crashed in Ramenskoye area about 25 miles from the airport.

Aaron Rodgers sinks birdie putt at Pebble Beach Pro
Rory McIlroy finished three shots off the pace in the first round as he made his debut at the AT&T Pebble Beach Pro-Am . Previous year he led through 36 holes before finishing 5th and there have been three other top tens in his eight starts.

Apple confirms iPhone source code leak
There are also concerns it could uncover new security vulnerabilities in iOS, which may be found by attackers. Apple though ruled out any such possibility claiming the iBoot process that has got leaked pertains to iOS 9.

Current Liverpool side better than 2005 CL winners, says Carragher
Van Dijk is expecting a hot reception but insists it will not impact his performance for his new club. Jurgen Klopp will speak with Virgil van Dijk ahead of his Southampton return.

Freezing temps can't stop Tonga's glistening flag bearer
The display of Tonga Winter Olympics pride will air tonight in America, but here's a sneak peek of what's to come. He said: 'I'm still alive today, so I was honest.

Four changes for Ireland
Joe Schmidt will put his side through their paces on the eve of their Six Nations clash against Italy. We want to get out there and score tries and a year ago the number of tries was fantastic.

Streelman and Hossler share Pebble Beach lead
Defending champion Jordan Spieth managed to get going, shooting a five-under 66 on Monterey Peninsula to be tied for 23rd. With so much sunshine Thursday across the Monterey Peninsula, that was inevitable.