Supreme Court Will Hear Case on Mandatory Fees to Unions

30 September, 2017, 15:59 | Author: Dustin Murphy
  • A Momentous Term For The Court

"With the Supreme Court agreeing to hear the Janus case, we are now one step closer to freeing over 5 million public sector teachers, police officers, firefighters, and other employees from the injustice of being forced to subsidize a union as a condition of working for their own government", NRTW President Mark Mix said in a statement provided by InsideSources.

"Unions have to represent everybody in the workplace but an individual worker does not have to become a member of the union, but all workers benefit from the wages and the quality healthcare, the things that are negotiated in the contract". "That is the power of class and collective action suits: They let workers pool their claims, making it possible for an attorney to earn enough to make the case worth pursuing". The arrangement was supposed to prevent non-members from "free riding", since the union has a legal duty to represent all workers.

The American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees - the largest public employee union in IL and the one at the center of the lawsuit - predicted victory for their side.

The justices last week granted review in Janus v. American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees Council 31, which could affect the treasuries and political might of all public-employee unions, including the American Federation of Teachers, the National Education Association, and their state and local affiliates.

Gorsuch's speech, one of his first since joining the court in April, came just a few days before the Supreme Court's begins its new term Monday. Our Never Trump friends should acknowledge that if Hillary Clinton had won the election, she would have appointed a justice to succeed Antonin Scalia who would have voted to keep public employees in a state of involuntary servitude to the unions, and the Democratic Party, forever. Without mandatory fees, workers who decline to join the union would still reap the benefits of the union without paying any of the cost.

A clear ruling from the high court has the potential to seriously disrupt the underlying model for unions representing public workers.


While the Janus case involves a different plaintiff from a different state (Illinois), the argument is the same: Collective bargaining by public-sector unions inherently involves political issues that trigger First Amendment rights, just like the overtly political union activities that nonmembers have long had the right to refuse to help pay for.

Janus vs. AFSCME challenges the constitutionality of compelling government workers to pay dues to a union to which they do not wish to join.

Public unions and worker advocates characterize challenges to fair-share fees as attacks on working people's ability to act collectively. The justices have already considered the question presented by the case twice without resolving it, but are nearly certain to do so during this go-round - with potentially serious implications for the union. "I am hopeful the court will see it that way in the end." said Governor Bruce Rauner.

"By its very nature, the activity of a government union is political", Rauner said in a Thursday interview with the Tribune.

An AFSCME statement calls the case a plan to "rig the economic rules against everyday working people". They also argue that having one representative of employees makes it easier to bargain and "ensure labor peace".

Two years ago, the Supreme Court agreed to hear this dispute and told the 9th Circuit to reconsider the issue. And if you pay dues, you have no say in whether the union uses the money to support political candidates, even if you oppose those candidates.

Recommended:

  • Dubai Is Building A New City That Mimics Life On Mars

    Dubai Is Building A New City That Mimics Life On Mars

    The United Arab Eremites has announced plans to build a model of hypothetical city on Mars , titled Mars Space City (MSC). The project aims at attracting "the best scientific minds from around the world", according to the press release.
    Miley Cyrus desperately tries to out-country Blake Shelton on 'The Voice'

    Miley Cyrus desperately tries to out-country Blake Shelton on 'The Voice'

    So it was a very, very hard decision for me because, like I said, I was so headstrong that I was going to choose Blake. Do you think she will win the competition? Still, his performance made quite the impression on all four judges .
    Construction of border wall prototypes begins in San Diego

    Construction of border wall prototypes begins in San Diego

    According to CBP, they "will inform future design standard (s) which will likely continue to evolve to meet (U.S. The contractors are erecting eight prototypes in San Diego - four made of concrete and four of other materials .
  • Turkey to open it's largest military base in Somalia

    Turkey to open it's largest military base in Somalia

    Most of the victims were civilians in a minibus which was passing the area when the vehicle bomb exploded. No group has yet claimed responsibility for the attack.
    J&K: Pakistan violates ceasefire along LoC; Indian Army retaliates

    J&K: Pakistan violates ceasefire along LoC; Indian Army retaliates

    The reports said that some villagers of the area had noticed the presence of four suspects when they were working in the fields. The incident had led to parts of the 740-km long LoC witnessing escalation in tensions.
    Twitter tests doubling of 140-character limit

    Twitter tests doubling of 140-character limit

    This suggests that users likely feel that they must edit their commentary or thoughts down in order to get their message across. Twitter product manager Aliza Rosen wrote, "Trying to cram your thoughts into a Tweet - we've all been there, and it's a pain".
  • United States  stance on Bombardier dispute is damaging diplomatic relations, says May

    United States stance on Bombardier dispute is damaging diplomatic relations, says May

    DUP leader Arlene Foster's influence has seen the Prime Minister lobbying US President Donald Trump during a recent visit to NY . Nor would he disclose the contingencies it will offer Delta Air Lines , which is slated to begin receiving CS100s next spring.
    Google tweaks search ads after European Union  shopping antitrust ruling

    Google tweaks search ads after European Union shopping antitrust ruling

    The European Commission fined Google $2.8 billion this summer after determining that Google acted abusively in shopping. Google presented its plans to the commission at the end of August but did not make them public until Wednesday.
    S. Korea says winter Olympics will be safe despite nuclear threat

    S. Korea says winter Olympics will be safe despite nuclear threat

    The IOC said it was helping North Korea prepare its athletes for the Games and would cover costs of their equipment if needed. North and South Korea remain technically at war after their 1950-53 conflict ended with a truce and not a peace treaty.
  • United Kingdom  warns Boeing it could lose defence contracts over Bombardier dispute

    United Kingdom warns Boeing it could lose defence contracts over Bombardier dispute

    The firm said the decision was "divorced from the reality about the financing of multibillion-dollar aircraft programmes". Boeing has driven the USA government's investigation into the CSeries, which competes in the 100- to 150-seat sector.
    Debra Messing Mad At Megyn Kelly For 'Gay Thing' Comment

    Debra Messing Mad At Megyn Kelly For 'Gay Thing' Comment

    Fonda went on to speak at length about the film , delving into her character and plot details with help from Redford. "Right now. You admit you've had work done, which I think is to your credit, but you look unbelievable ", she said.

    Current Manchester United team 'strongest' in post-Ferguson era

    In three of the four in-person meetings between CSKA and Manchester United , the "total less than 2.5" bet was played. His bright start is in contrast to last season when he struggled to adapt to the demands of English football.


Popular

Mattis arrives in Afghanistan as rockets hit Kabul airport
Both pledged continued support for the government so the country "doesn't again become a safe haven for global terrorists". He said the insurgents mined the area around the base to prevent authorities from sending in reinforcements.

Twitter aims to enhance appeal with new 280-character tweet limit
Need more room to type those deep thoughts? Most Japanese tweets are 15 characters while most English tweets are 34. They acknowledged that some people on Twitter have strong emotional attachment to the current limit.

Falcons hold on to beat Lions 30-26 thanks to National Football League rule
As the team itself pointed out, the offense got a snap off in seven seconds in last year's game-tying drive versus the Vikings. The play was initially ruled short of the goal line but that official's decision was successfully challenged by Atlanta .

Over 122000 people flee Bali volcano on eruption alert
This is official information from the government, which has, itself, evacuated more than 80,000 residents from the immediate area. Agung, about 45 miles to the northeast of the tourist hotspot of Kuta, is among more than 120 active volcanoes in Indonesia .

Barcelona focusing on football, not independence
Joaquin Forn said officials are determined to proceed with Sunday's vote, even though Spain's government says it is illegal and can not happen.

Evidence inconclusive on Otto Warmbier being tortured in North Korea: Coroner
As we looked at him and tried to comfort him, it looked like someone had taken pliers and tried to rearrange his bottom teeth. North Korean officials have said Warmbier was released on humanitarian grounds and had been treated respectfully.

The Strange Political Race in Alabama
Rather than excising bigotry and extremism, they've sat back and remained silent as it's metastasized within the Republican Party. But it's far more important than that indicates - it's a marker in estimating President Donald Trump's hold on the GOP.

Siemens, Alstom merge rail operations to create giant European train business
The merger of Alstom and Siemens Mobility's rail businesses has been confirmed in a joint statement released by the companies. The merged company will be called Siemens Alstom , with headquarters based in Germany and rolling stock based in France.

Pixel 2 Smartphones Rumored To Have Portrait Mode, New Music Recognition Feature
What Google is trying to imply is that time has come for Nexus 5X and Nexus 6P owners to start looking for a new smartphone. The next rumored feature for the Pixel 2 smartphones is what's now being called as " Music Recognition ".

Saudi king decrees women be allowed to drive
Critics took to Twitter to denounce the decision, accusing the government of "bending the verses of Sharia". Some women have been arrested and jailed for defying the ban.